2.29 (1966)

Solved

Does the class of finite groups in which every proper abelian subgroup is contained in a proper normal subgroup coincide with the class of finite groups in which every proper abelian subgroup is contained in a proper normal subgroup of prime index?

Progress

No. Let $B$ be a finite group such that $B = [B, B] \neq 1$ and let $r$ be the rank of $B$. Put $A = \bigoplus_{p \mid |B|} (\mathbb{Z}/p\mathbb{Z})^{r+1}$ and $G = A \wr B$. We define a homomorphism $\varphi : G \to A$ by setting $(bf)^\varphi = \sum_{x \in B} f(x)$, where $b \in B$ and $f \in F = \text{Fun}(B, A)$. Suppose that $f^b = f$ for $b \in B$ and $f \in F$. It is clear that $f^\varphi \in nA$, where $n = |b|$. In particular, $C_F(b)^\varphi \leqslant pA \leqslant O_{p'}(A)$ if $p \mid n$. Every proper abelian subgroup $H$ of $G$ is contained in a proper normal subgroup. Indeed, we may assume that $H \not\leqslant F$. We fix an element $bf \in H$, where $f \in F$, $b \in B$, $b \neq 1$. Let $p$ be a prime dividing $|b|$. For any $h \in H \cap F$ we have $bfh = hbf = bhbf = bfh^b$, whence $h = h^b$. Hence $(H \cap F)^\varphi \leqslant C_F(b)^\varphi \leqslant O_{p'}(A)$. If $T$ is the full preimage of $O_{p'}(A)$ in $G$, then $G/T \cong (\mathbb{Z}/p\mathbb{Z})^{r+1}$ and therefore $H/H \cap T$ is an elementary abelian $p$-group. The rank of it is $\leqslant r$, since $H/H \cap T$ embeds into $B$ and $H \cap F \leqslant H \cap T$. Thus, $HT$ is a proper normal subgroup containing $H$. On the other hand, $F$ is a proper abelian subgroup that is not contained in any proper normal subgroup of prime index, since $G/F \cong B = [B, B]$. (G. M. Bergman, I. M. Isaacs, Letter of June, 17, 1974.)

Comments

All comments are the responsibility of the user. Comments appearing on this page are not verified for correctness. Please keep posts mathematical and on topic. If you want to submit a proof (or a partial proof), please use the dedicated proof submission form rather than posting it in the comments.
Order by newest first or oldest first.

No comments yet. Be the first to comment.

Proof claims

Proof claims are the responsibility of the submitter. Appearance here does not mean the claim has been checked for mathematical correctness. Moderators only screen for spam, abuse, and obviously low-effort submissions.

No proof claims yet.